The Best and Worst of Doctor Who: Series 4

j4oww2x

For previous installments:

The Best:

Turn Left

tumblr_lpj7ndXhaI1qcxltp

The Den of Geek review best articulates how awesome this episode really is:

tumblr_mibw0qnGjx1qlk4meo1_250

If Russell T Davies is prowling the Internet tonight, as these words are being written, then surely he’s feeling some sort of vindication. Frequently championed for his story arcs, and yet chastised for his individual episodes, for the second week running he’s shown his writing team, and the many assorted critics he’s faced, just how it should be done.

Let’s make no bones about this: Turn Left was really, really good.

tumblr_mibw0qnGjx1qlk4meo2_250

It’s also the kind of episode you can only really do once in a blue moon, and it didn’t take long for RTD to get going. With a fairly poor special effect to kick the shebang off, it’s not too long before Donna is separated from the Doctor, courtesy of an insistent fortune teller.

Of course, this being Doctor Who, and this being before the credits, there’s usually danger in the offing, and so it proves to be. Before long, the fortune teller has tracked Donna’s life back to a single pivotal decision, about whether to turn her car left, towards a life with the Doctor, or right, towards a life without him. And before you can say Sliding Doors or Back To The Future Part II, her decision is reversed, and much of the episode is dedicated to the resultant repercussions. In fact, the Doctor is shoehorned out of it, only appearing at the start and the end, as the focus is very much of Donna, and what looks like her fatal journey.

tumblr_mibw0qnGjx1qlk4meo3_250

This gives RTD the chance to serve up a bit of a compilation album of moments from the last few years, albeit viewed from a different standpoint, and with very different consequences. Thus, we head back to The Runaway Bride where, without the intervention of Donna, the Doctor dies. We also get a look at what would have happened in Smith & Jones without the Doctor (Martha dies), we find out that Sarah-Jane buys it too, that Captain Jack is on the Sontaran homeworld, that two of the Torchwood team have perished, and that the Titanic from Voyage Of The Damned has crashed into London. Killing pretty much everyone (even American gets it later in the episode, courtesy of – by all things – the Adipose. They’ll be delighted about that).

tumblr_mibw0qnGjx1qlk4meo4_250

Thus, Donna and her family – who survived only thanks to a winning raffle ticket (for the cheapest-looking luxury break I think I’ve ever seen) and a bit of advice from Billie Piper (who we’re coming to shortly) – are sent with other refugees of London up to Leeds, where they’re crammed into a small house with many others, some of whom head off, ominously, to a labour camp by the episode’s end.

The upshot of this is that not only does Tate get to flex her acting muscles, pulling off an episode hinged around her really rather well, but it also gives Bernard Cribbins a decent amount to do as well. And heck, could many of the supporting players we’ve met over the past few years learn something from him. When tears well up in his eyes, as the truck heads off to the aforementioned labour camp, it feels so much more substantial than the shoehorning in of another EastEnders cast-off would have managed. More Cribbins, please.

tumblr_mibw0qnGjx1qlk4meo5_250

Also into the mix, of course, was the returning Rose Tyler. Her job was to pop up at various points throughout the episode and nudge Donna in the right direction – in effect, do the Doctor’s job – and she was mainly kept in the background for much of the time. Was it us, though, or did her speech sound a little off? She’d either had a bad trip to the dentist, or perhaps this ties into the return of the two magical words, Bad Wolf, at the end. She certainly sounded more like the Rose from the end of The Parting Of The Ways (but I can’t remember what she wore in that episode, so can’t say with certainty about the importance of her outfit) than the one who traipsed around in every other episode, and we wait and see whether this is a deliberate ploy or not.

tumblr_mibw0qnGjx1qlk4meo6_250

But this was, ultimately, an episode about Donna, and one that had the side effect of showing the fragility of the Doctor himself. Because for all the talk of his loneliness, and how the assistants can sometimes end up more as narrative devices than integral parts of a storyline, here we see for certain that without a companion, he’s a dead man. As simple as that. The assistants save him, allowing him to save the world.

tumblr_mibw0qnGjx1qlk4meo7_250

It’s surely certain too that he’ll be companion shopping again come the fifth series in 2010. On the back of Catherine Tate in this episode was not only a ropey looking creature that had leapt straight out of the Davison era of the show, but also a big target, with an arrow above her head proclaiming “Donna’s going to die”. I’m doubting that too many people were surprised when Rose told Donna that she was going to buy it, and we go into the last two episodes knowing that she’s thrown herself in front of a truck to re-alter fate once more. It’s one pickle that the Doctor is unlikely to be able to pull her out of, for all the psychic paper in the world.

tumblr_mibw0qnGjx1qlk4meo8_250

But then he has problems of his own. Why did he meet Donna for a second time, and was someone in control of that? Why have more bees gone missing? How can he stave off the coming darkness? And how, for the second time, did he miss the Bad Wolf stuff all around him?

tumblr_lvowskHuay1qabkrxo2_250

The Worst:

Partners In Crime

-Partners-in-Crime-doctor-who-32929329-245-175

This episode follows up on when the Doctor and Donna Noble met in The Runaway Bride.

tumblr_lye48x8K1o1qb8o02o1_250

tumblr_lye48x8K1o1qb8o02o2_250

tumblr_lye48x8K1o1qb8o02o3_250

tumblr_lye48x8K1o1qb8o02o4_250

tumblr_lye48x8K1o1qb8o02o5_250

tumblr_lye48x8K1o1qb8o02o6_250

tumblr_lye48x8K1o1qb8o02o7_250

tumblr_lye48x8K1o1qb8o02o8_250

After that, he met Martha Jones in Smith and Jones.

tumblr_mi1631dS7a1qhycheo6_r1_250

Martha Jones left in The Last of the Time Lords.

tumblr_inline_mtgbfpAiN11r4rbqj

Unlike during the Steven Moffat Era, who likes to have stronger opening stories (The Eleventh Hour, The Impossible Astronaut/Day of the Moon, Asylum of the Daleks, and Deep Breath), the Russell T Davies generally never really started off with a strong story. Nearly every episode in Series 4, however, is utterly fantastic, but I had to come to decision.

tumblr_mej310KCw21rs7n9lo2_250

tumblr_nq6dkkTODR1uyei3mo1_500

tumblr_m6ypakLm6f1qdlrn2o2_250

tumblr_mxzf4cB5P91r539fdo3_250

tumblr_m9kdt4F0Ml1qmrla4

This episode has several great funny moments, as seen above, but doesn’t add much to the overall story arc. The main foe, Ms. Foster, was a bit of a straw herself.

tumblr_muwigkcvFf1qafyzfo6_250

Donna did play at least once in the story the Damsel in Distress (see Feminist Frequency‘s Damsel in Distress Series) partially being why it was the worst for this season.

tumblr_n3qdflCXCp1t15xv3o1_250

partners in crime 3

This makes the appearance of Rose the only part worth watching throughout the entire episode.

tumblr_lrms12Zca41r1hdnho1_500

Next is the best and worst of Series 3.

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “The Best and Worst of Doctor Who: Series 4

  1. Pingback: The Best and Worst of Doctor Who: Series 3 | The Progressive Democrat

  2. Pingback: The Best and Worst of Doctor Who: Series 2 | The Progressive Democrat

  3. Pingback: A Special Look at: Time Heist | The Progressive Democrat

  4. Pingback: The Best and Worst of Doctor Who: Series 1 | The Progressive Democrat

  5. Pingback: The Best and Worst of The Sarah Jane Adventures: Series 5 | The Progressive Democrat

  6. Pingback: The Best and Worst of Doctor Who: Series 9 | The Progressive Democrat

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s